Register  | Login


Bob Humphrey is the Biology & Deer Behavior field editor for Buckmasters Whitetail Magazine and holds similar titles with other major hunting publications. He currently lives in Maine with his wife and two children. For more information about Bob, visit his website at

Click here to email your questions to "Ask the Biologist."


Better Than Oaks?
If you still haven’t heard about the return of the American chestnut, you’re not the only one.

Better Than Oaks?

QUESTION: I recently read an article on Dunstan chestnut trees, and how deer really love them. It explains how deer prefer them over white oak acorns. Is there any truth to this? How would the swamp chestnut oak compare to the Dunstan chestnut for deer? — Curtis L.

ANSWER: For those unfamiliar, the American chestnut was pretty much wiped out by disease back in the 1940s. The tree you’re referring to is a cultivar originally developed by Robert Dunstan, a plant breeder. As the story goes, a friend of Dunstan’s found a single living American chestnut in Ohio and sent him some cuttings. Dunstan grew them to flowering and crossed them with Chinese chestnuts, creating a strain with high disease resistance and good nut and tree quality. He then cross bred them back with the pure American chestnut to develop a blight-resistant and nearly pure American Chestnut.

Dunstan chestnut trees have survived for over 30 years from Maine to central florida and throughout the Midwest with no blight infection whatsoever. They’re sold through Chestnut Hill Tree Farm in Florida and Realtree Nursery at

As for their attractiveness to deer, I haven’t seen results from any empirical scientific experiments but have seen some pretty convincing anecdotal evidence. And it’s not surprising. American chestnuts were once among the most common hardwood trees in eastern North America, making up an estimated 25 percent of the eastern hardwood forest.

Furthermore, chestnuts are nutritionally superior to acorns, containing approximately 40 percent carbohydrates, compared to about 10 percent for white oak acorns; 10 percent protein compared to only 4 percent for white oak acorns; and 2 percent fat, compared to 10 percent in acorns. And deer have an innate ability to determine the most nutritious foods.

They also make a better choice for mast orchards as they grow faster and bigger, sometimes bearing in two to five years, where a white oak might not bear for 20 years. Chestnuts can grow 60-80 feet tall, and they lack the cyclical nature of oaks because they flower later in spring – after late frosts that could cause widespread acorn failures and starvation years for wildlife.

Click Here To Email Your Questions to "Ask The Biologist."






How do different deer species react to hunters?
Could you tell me the reason why if you jump a whitetail, it runs and doesn’t stop. But, if you jump a mule deer, it will run a short distance, stop and look back. My question is what will a blackta...
When is the rut in South Carolina?
I live in Lexington, South Carolina. I am 48 years old and I’ve hunted deer for 41 years. When is the Rut in my state? My father, who is 83 years young, says it is always the second week of October...
Are irregular racks caused by genes or an injury?
I shot a 24-point buck with my bow a few years ago. The rack is fairly symmetrical. The body weight is only about 100 pounds, about the size of a medium-size doe. Is this just a fluke, or could the...
Food Plots, Logging Trails and Pine Woods
I live in central Massachusetts. We raised cattle for 30 years, but the cows are gone now. We selective cut about 10 years ago, and the deer love the white pine groves where the cows used to graze....
How do I keep more bucks on my property?
I reside in the great state of New York and am hunting a 100-acre piece property, all wooded. We have no space to plant any kind of food plot without a great deal of land clearing. There is a great ...
Page 28 of 30First   Previous   21  22  23  24  25  26  27  [28]  29  30  Next   Last   
Google+ Buckmasters on Pinterest Follow Us On Instagram! Join Buckmasters Buckmasters on YouTube Follow Us On Twitter Buckmasters on Facebook!

Become A Buckmasters Nations Fan!