Big Buck 411 Blog

An Indiana Mass Monster

An Indiana Mass Monster

By Mark Melotik

Dedicated Indiana deer hunters Robbie Roland and his wife Casie know that certain mature bucks have a knack of eluding hunters. But there is a definite, two-pronged benefit to that elusiveness. With age comes increased antler mass and plenty of inches. And sometimes, a whole lot more than you’d think.

Back in 2021, Robbie noticed a younger buck with a lot of trash points and loads of potential. It was running with an old 8-pointer, which was Robbie’s target buck that season. Once the pre-rut arrived, the older deer pushed the younger buck out of the area.

Both bucks returned the next summer. The younger deer had grown a bunch of extra points, but the old 8-pointer soon pushed its rival out of the area yet again. So the Rolands focused on hunting the estimated 9 1/2-year-old 8-pointer, but never closed the deal.

In 2023, both deer again returned, but now the herd’s power dynamics had shifted. Now past mature, the old 8-pointer was no match for its younger rival, which had now ballooned into a jaw-dropping monster.

On opening day of Indiana’s gun season, Casie shot a great buck behind their home. Robbie left the property where The Big One lived and went to help her, but several days later — Thanksgiving Day — Robbie was back in his target buck’s preferred haunt. That morning, he glimpsed the huge deer deep in a thicket; it offered no shot but his confidence was renewed.

Rather than leave for Thanksgiving meals, he decided to stay and hunt the afternoon, too. It was a good call. As daylight waned, The Big One reappeared, but Robbie’s first two shots with his single-shot .350 Legend missed clean. After a feverish second reload, and with the buck now trotting into a nearby field, Robbie’s third shot struck just behind the big deer’s shoulder. It took off running but crashed in sight just before reaching a property line.

The Indiana giant was certainly worth the wait. At an estimated 6 1/2 years, the almost-scary-massive buck was officially scored at 233 6/8 in BTR’s Irregular category.

For the complete story of the hunt for this Hancock County monster — including details of its run-ins with several other local hunters — be sure to check out the feature-packed Fall issue of Rack magazine.

To get your FREE, no-hassle digital subscription to RACK, visit: www.buckmasters.com/Magazines/Rack/Subscribe

Copyright 2024 by Buckmasters, Ltd.

Copyright 2020 by Buckmasters, Ltd